OK.
If the new Chaos Space Marines codex is indeed in effect, I'm going to be bringing them.
I recommend that we go back to using the Warlord traits straight out of the book (just pick one table and roll on it). The reason for this is that CSM has its own Warlord traits table, and has certain HQ's that come with one specific warlord trait and don't allow a roll. This tells me that GW is using access to warlord traits as a balancing factor for the power level of units, and we are mucking with that by making it so that HQ's without specific traits are allowed 2 rolls, picking the bettter one.
if we DO use the "pick 2 tables and roll on both", do CSM get to roll 1 on the CSM table and 1 on a "book table" and pick the better one?
Finally.... I want to point out something to the TO's which may be helpful when it comes to validating ppl's army lists. A lot of people are talking about running Typhus and then taking giant units of Plague Zombies... this doesn't work because Typhus' plague zombie rule says that the zombie units cannot have any options. Extra zombies is an option. (Extra guys is an optional upgrade for the unit, it's listed in exactly the same place as all other options).