Plainville's Official "Unofficial" Tuesday 40k

[Grimwulfe]

Fateweaver can make someone reroll?  I assume through psychic powers?

[Benjamin]

Fateweaver can make someone reroll?  I assume through psychic powers?

They had to 4+ the interpretation of Fateweaver's special ability to re-roll one die per turn. To me, it was pretty clear that Fateweaver's ability only applied to rolls the Daemon player makes, because how can a player re-roll dice he never rolled in the first place? The arguing interpretation, that Fatey can force anyone to re-roll any one die per turn, won the 4+ rules roll off.

[Grimwulfe]

Oh hell no!!  I agree with you on this Ben.  Its a reroll on one of his rolls not the other players.

[MM3791]

Yea the wording is dicey imo, but I got my info from Bell of Lost Souls.. but perhaps they are wrong. Good to know, the game me and Brad played was just a friendly game so its not a huge deal. Like I said it was a good game, going forward I will interpret it as "daemon player" only 

When in doubt we always have Ben Solomon (to resolve the issue I will cut the model in half) lol

[bradpowers]

Yeah, no offense to the internet, but I generally don't trust it any further than I can throw it.  Saying something on the internet isn't a qualification, it merely means you've said something on the internet.  To be fair, I'm saying this on the internet.

[Grimwulfe]

Brad you just blew my mind!

[Typhus]

I'm so confused as to how anyone can interpret that Fateweaver can make his opponent re-roll...

[andalucien]

"This staff allows you to re-roll a single D6 of your choice once per turn..."

According to that, you can't make your opponent re-roll.  But, you can re-roll a dice your opponent rolled

However, this would be stupid.

[Benjamin]

It's just one of many cases in which GW could have written the rule more clearly. I think they have a fear of being highly specific.

[PhoenixFire]

It's just one of many cases in which GW could have written the rule more clearly. I think they have a fear of being highly specific.

In related news: The Stargate malfunctioned which sent Jack O'Neil back in time. Who told me when the Space Marine codex hits next month there will be new ambiguous rules and loopholes.

[Loranus]

It's just one of many cases in which GW could have written the rule more clearly. I think they have a fear of being highly specific.

In related news: The Stargate malfunctioned which sent Jack O'Neil back in time. Who told me when the Space Marine codex hits next month there will be new ambiguous rules and loopholes.

I know I am excited to argue to be OP.

[Dan Bunker]

I'm looking for an 1850 game tomorrow night. Competitive play practicing for NOVA. Not looking to curbstomp people looking for practice and critiquing for both sides. Post here if you want a game, I'm traveling over an hour so if no one responds I will be absent.

[MM3791]

I'm looking for an 1850 game tomorrow night. Competitive play practicing for NOVA. Not looking to curbstomp people looking for practice and critiquing for both sides. Post here if you want a game, I'm traveling over an hour so if no one responds I will be absent.

Hey Dan, I might be down for a game.. what time you thinking?

[Dan Bunker]

anytime is good. whole day available

[MM3791]

That sounds good, want to plan for 4:00?