i play elsewhere also where people play more of the all jack or beast list and enjoyable lists.
All the more reason to put in some infantry. You saw what it does to your all jack list. Throw in some indrian skirmishers and some zellots and see what happens, rather than dropping the faction.
just because somebody doesnt like doing ists to win doesnt mean it cant have a good game and be enjoyable for the player.
If that is your impression of our group you are seriously delusional. YOU asked for feedback on wither your list was good. Our help does not in any way mean we don't think you should play what you want. Just man up and realize you will sacrifice your win loss record (which now reflects an army you don't own) in order to play whatever strikes you as fun. Many of us have done the same thing in the past. I played Ashlyn for a long time. Not exactly a power caster. Ian literally used dice to determine his lists. Steve plays a list based exclusively on theme.
all i asked was for tips and tricks with the model not for people to say that my list is shitty and cant win etc.
NO. You specifically asked to know if people thought the list was garbage. Lying about what you asked and geting bent out of shape over it doesn't demonstrate a mature approach to the game.
I don't mean to chase you away but when you ask something specific and get a specific answer don't blame those helping you in their spare time.
id lose to people at bg anyways since you are all expirienced. id rather enjoy osing than lose and not be happy. the wins are from people who have equal expirience to me, since im an only child anyways.
There are like 3 people at battlegrounds who are experienced and currently playing with any frequency. Several more are inexperienced. Pick up a game with Rick, Jay, etc. If you don't want to challenge up the ladder.
When I was brand new to the game I got trampled by more (qty) experienced players than you are facing and I still enjoyed it. It taught me a lot and they were fun games. It is all about your attitude. You CAN have fun loosing. Especially if you listen to the advice people freely give after the game.
